TECHNICAL ARTICLE

Heat Recovery Ventilation: Efficiency, Types and Selection

Compare heat recovery ventilation types and calculate sensible effectiveness. Review moisture recovery, fan energy, bypass and frost with worked examples.

1. What does heat recovery reduce?

Heat recovery transfers energy between exhaust and outdoor air, reducing ventilation conditioning demand. It does not eliminate the need for ventilation: the aim is to supply the required outdoor air at suitable conditions with lower energy use. Begin with airflow and operation, not a single catalogue efficiency.

Office, residential, kitchen and healthcare exhaust have different odour, grease, particulate and hygiene characteristics. These affect acceptable recovery arrangements. Establish room pressure relationships and outdoor-air requirements before selecting a high-efficiency device.

2. Initial selection inputs

Record supply and extract flows separately; pressurisation, separate exhausts and leakage can make them unequal. Define winter, summer and intermediate-season operation.

Required inputs include outdoor/indoor temperatures and humidity ratios, local pressure, design and part-load flows, exhaust contaminants and permitted transfer, device/filter/duct losses, frost protection, bypass, condensate, access, fan electricity, sound and controls.

Use adopted weather data and document the manufacturer's test conditions beside project inputs. Do not treat effectiveness at one test point as constant throughout the year.

3. Sensible, latent and total effectiveness

Sensible recovery reduces a temperature difference; moisture transfer reduces a humidity-ratio difference. Total energy performance involves enthalpy. These quantities are not interchangeable. A non-moisture-transferring plate exchanger does not change supply humidity ratio merely because it changes temperature.

For a balanced illustrative case:

εT = (Tsupply,out − Toutdoor,in) / (Textract,in − Toutdoor,in)

This definition assumes specific measurement boundaries. Fan heat, unbalanced flow and leakage affect measured results; match manufacturer and hand-calculation definitions. Assess moisture and enthalpy effectiveness separately.

Eurovent guidance discusses these distinctions and leakage effects: https://www.eurovent.eu/publications/eurovent-17-11-2015-guidelines-for-heat-recovery/ and https://www.eurovent.eu/publications/eurovent-17-14-moisture-recovery-in-ventilation-and-air-conditioning-systems/

4. Select exchanger type for the application

Plate arrangements use separated passages, with moisture transfer depending on the product. Rotary exchangers transfer heat and, for some types, moisture, but carryover and leakage require assessment. Run-around coils connect physically separated streams and introduce pump and frost considerations.

Selection issueAssessment
Contaminant transferCompare exchanger type and leakage data with application requirements
Moisture recoveryCheck seasonal psychrometrics and actual moisture transfer
Distant air streamsConsider layout and run-around circuits
FrostCheck the manufacturer's protection and capacity effects
MaintenanceShow access to exchanger, filters, rotor and drain

Maximum effectiveness is not the sole selection criterion. Unacceptable contaminant transfer remains a problem regardless of energy savings.

5. Winter example: downstream heating load

Assume balanced flow of 2,000 m³/h, outdoor air at 0 °C, extract entering at 22 °C and temperature effectiveness 0.75. Fan heat, leakage and frosting are excluded.

Tsupply,out = 0 + 0.75 × (22 − 0) = 16.5 °C

With density 1.20 kg/m³ and specific heat 1.006 kJ/(kg·K), volume flow is 0.556 m³/s and mass flow approximately 0.667 kg/s. Heating outdoor air directly from 0 to 22 °C requires about 14.75 kW. After recovery, heating from 16.5 to 22 °C requires about 3.69 kW.

QuantityApproximate result
Air temperature after recovery16.5 °C
Sensible heating without recovery14.75 kW
Downstream heater load3.69 kW
Sensible load reduction11.06 kW

This describes one design instant. Frost protection or preheating can alter consumption. Annual savings require weather and operating-hour analysis.

6. Summer example and the importance of moisture

At outdoor 35 °C, extract 25 °C and temperature effectiveness 0.70, supply leaves at about 28 °C. This describes temperature only. A sensible-only exchanger does not eliminate the latent cooling load of humid outdoor air.

Find both temperature and humidity ratio after recovery, then calculate the coil's enthalpy difference to its leaving condition. Calculating from the recovered state and then multiplying the whole load by effectiveness counts recovery twice.

Even an enthalpy exchanger requires actual summer performance data. Its moisture transfer must align with the dehumidification target; its presence does not mean the cooling coil has no latent duty.

7. Fan energy and net benefit

The exchanger adds resistance. Compare thermal savings with fan electricity using heating/cooling efficiency, rather than treating thermal and electrical kW as equivalent.

Approximate fan power is P = V̇ × Δp / ηtotal. With 0.556 m³/s, an additional 150 Pa in each stream and total efficiency 0.60, the added demand is approximately 139 W per fan, or 278 W for two. These are assumed values.

In the winter example, 11.06 kW of thermal reduction at an assumed heating COP of 3 corresponds to about 3.69 kW less electricity. Subtracting 0.278 kW of additional fan demand gives approximately 3.41 kW net reduction at that instant. COP, airflow and weather vary; this is not an annual saving.

8. Leakage, fouling and pressure relationships

Exhaust transfer into supply depends on stream pressures and exchanger operation as well as casing tightness. Interpret measures such as EATR and OACF alongside their test conditions and product data.

Where contaminant transfer is unacceptable, another device or arrangement may be needed. Adding a generic airflow safety factor does not resolve leakage: verify pressure relationships and approved operating conditions.

Dirty filters can alter fan flow and power. Check clean and dirty conditions separately. An inaccessible high-performance device may fail to maintain its efficiency in service.

9. Frost protection, bypass and condensate

Exhaust moisture can condense and freeze in winter. Preheating, bypass, flow changes and other protection are product-specific. Assess their effects on supply temperature, ventilation and electricity.

During intermediate seasons, suitable outdoor air may provide free cooling and heat recovery may be unwanted. Evaluate bypass logic using temperature and, where needed, moisture or enthalpy. No single method suits every climate and application.

Condensate drains and traps must suit internal pressure. Use product requirements rather than an arbitrary trap depth. Coordinate cleaning access and freezing risk.

10. Controls, measurement and handover

Monitor entering/leaving temperatures, fans, filter pressure, bypass and frost status. Include humidity sensing where moisture performance matters. Place sensors so fan or coil effects do not confuse the measurement boundary.

Commission both stream flows, pressure relationships, leakage checks and sensor accuracy. Identify every measurement point used for effectiveness. An unstable measurement cannot establish catalogue performance.

Handover should describe filter class and replacement criteria, exchanger cleaning, condensate maintenance and frost protection. Sustained efficiency depends on operation as much as selection.

11. Checklist and common mistakes

Check actual supply/extract balance; clearly identify temperature, moisture or enthalpy effectiveness; recalculate outdoor-air duty after recovery; assess moisture and leakage; include fan demand and dirty filters; establish frost-protection effects; and show bypass, drains and maintenance access.

Common errors are equating temperature effectiveness with total-energy efficiency, ignoring moisture, counting recovery twice and extending laboratory performance to the whole year. Document measurement boundaries and operating conditions for each performance value.

12. Summer operation and latent load

Winter temperature effectiveness alone does not describe summer total-energy behaviour. For outdoor 35 °C, extract 24 °C and illustrative sensible effectiveness 0.70:

Tsupply,out = 35 − 0.70 × (35 − 24) = 27.3 °C

At 1,000 m³/h, density 1.2 kg/m³ and specific heat 1.006 kJ/(kg·K), sensible reduction is about 2.58 kW. Calculate remaining latent demand separately. Treating a sensible exchanger as a moisture-recovery device can mis-size the coil and drainage.

Bypassing can help when outdoor air is cool and the room needs cooling, but humidity and internal loads also matter. Leakage through a closed bypass or a faulty sensor can cause unwanted reheating. Define normal, free-cooling, frost and fire/alarm modes separately.

13. Show the energy and hygiene balance in the selection report

Compare devices at the same flows, outdoor/extract conditions and filter state. Evaluate fan electricity, maintenance, bypass and hours rather than buying from an efficiency percentage alone. Multiplying one instantaneous load reduction by 8,760 hours is not a sound annual estimate.

Exhaust contamination and transfer risk form part of the design basis. Assess leakage, carryover, pressure relationships and product limits for rotary, plate and other systems. Do not choose a device that transfers polluted exhaust to clean air solely for energy savings.

Show traps, exchanger cleaning and filter access on drawings. Acceptance testing should confirm not only balanced flow but simultaneous measurements at suitable sensor positions.

14. Sources and scope

Temperature, effectiveness and fan examples are independent educational assumptions. Final selection requires current product tests, application hygiene conditions, local requirements and verified air states.

← All articlesTechnical feedback →